American Journey Cat Food Review | Recalls & Ratings in 2021

American Journey Cat Food

This is our review of American Journey cat food in 2021.

American Journey is Chewy’s exclusive brand of pet food that was launched in 2017. 

Although most products made by American Journey are dog foods, they also cater to cats with their extensive range of grain-free formulas and wet foods.

American Journey is a highly affordable, value-for-money option for many pet owners because Chewy can sell its products competitively by streamlining production processes. The company prides itself on formulating cat foods with high-quality ingredients and is backed by Chewy’s excellent customer service.

I’m a cat owner passionate about helping other cat owners find the best cat food for their furry friends. So I researched the different American Journey cat food currently available to find out if this brand is the best choice for you.

Keep reading this American Journey cat food review to find out more information about what I discovered.

About American Journey

American Journey Cat Food

Many pet owners are familiar with Chewy, a popular pet food supplier that is based online. Chewy prides itself on its excellent customer service and convenient autoship plans for pet owners shopping for cat food and other pet supplies.

After the company had huge success selling dog food from other leading brands, Chewy decided to formulate its first exclusive pet food product line. American Journey offers an extensive range of wet and dry foods.

And because Chewy cuts out the middleman and produces the brand internally, the company can offer American Journey at a highly competitive price and provide high-quality nutritional diets.

Many cat owners on a tight budget can take advantage of regular promotions too.

Chewy primarily set out to create an affordable option for pet parents that want the best quality possible. This brand of cat food only uses natural, whole ingredients. It excludes common allergens like wheat, soy, poultry by-products, and artificial fillers.

The History Behind American Journey Cat Food

The company behind American Journey, Chewy, is a relatively new business. Chewy was founded by Ryan Cohen and Michael Day in 2011. And since then, Chewy has seen extraordinary growth year on year. The company is now responsible for over 51% of online pet food transactions in the United States alone.

As we previously mentioned, Chewy formulated American Journey after seeing tremendous growth and success selling other leading pet food brands.

American Journey cannot be purchased on any other online retailer and remains exclusively manufactured and distributed by Chewy.  

In 2017, Chewy was purchased by PetSmart for $3.35 billion, which was the largest sum paid for an e-commerce business at the present time. However, on October 26, 2020, PetSmart Inc announced they would be selling all its shares in Chewy. [1]

Before this announcement, pet owners could purchase American Journey through Chewy or PetSmart, but now the pet food brand is only available for purchase on Chewy. 

Where is American Journey Manufactured? 

American Journey is primarily made in the United States solely for Chewy. But unfortunately, there is limited information about which company oversees the manufacturing process of American Journey. 

Chewy does outsource the production of this brand to a third-party factory. Some of the American Journey formulas are made in a facility in Kansas. 

Most of the ingredients in American Journey cat foods are sourced in the United States; however, a limited amount of ingredients are sometimes imported.

dog eating

Controversies and Legal Concerns

American Journey is a relatively new brand with a limited history of controversies and legal issues. To date, there have been no recalls of any American Journey cat food products.

However, the promotion of specific food brands by online pet food retailers is largely controversial as these types of business models drive sales away from other competitors. 

Chewy can drive down the production costs of their brand by cutting out the middleman and offering affordable prices and promotions of their products. 

But recently, Chewy has become subject to a class-action lawsuit against numerous pet food brands, including American Journey. The lawsuit originated because some limited ingredient formulas contained ingredients that were claimed to be excluded. [2,3]

American Journey has several formulas that exclude common allergen ingredients such as grains, soy, wheat, or artificial fillers. However, following independent tests, it was discovered that some of these foods still contained these ingredients. 

American Journey is currency accused of false advertising because some pet food formulas are labeled as grain-free, corn-free, or soy-free.

Misleading labels can be hazardous for cats with food allergies who need a specifically formulated, limited ingredient formula to avoid adverse reactions.

Quality of Ingredients

Meat

American Journey prides itself on using high-quality ingredients. Compared to many other pet food brands, it’s safe to say they do an excellent job at it. All the products from American Journey offer balanced nutrition that meets the daily requirements recommended by AAFCO.

One thing to note is that American Journey only advertises that “top industry professionals” have aided in developing their products. In contrast, many reputable cat food brands are created with the assistance of certified veterinary professionals or nutritionists.

All of the cat foods made by American Journey feature real animal-based protein sources as a first ingredient.

Most budget options will use plant-based ingredients as protein sources to reduce costs. However, animal proteins are fundamental to a cat’s diet because they are obligate carnivores.

American Journey will sometimes use plant-based protein ingredients such as peas to boost the overall crude protein content. However, most of the formulas will have several animal proteins to contribute to the overall protein.

Meat-based protein ingredients will give your cat healthy amino fats which support the overall health of their skin and coat. Below is a comparison of the average crude percentages of all American Journey pet foods against all chewy dry foods.

American Journey Cat Food Review

Many of the American journey recipes will exclude common allergens like wheat, corn, soy, gluten, and by-products. These common allergen ingredients can cause severe adverse reactions in sensitive cats.

The higher protein content, average fat, and moderate carbohydrate content of American Journey formulas make them suitable for many cats. This pet food brand also offers limited ingredient formulas that provide unique, additional nutritional support for cats that need them.

Until recently, American Journey mainly formulated dog food that catered to large breeds. However, the company has recently expanded into cat food and offers small dog breed formulas.


American Journey Cat Food Brands

Chewy developed American Journey has a limited selection of cat foods currently. However, their diverse use of ingredients provides additional nutrition for cats with varying needs.

Always speak to your veterinarian before making any permanent changes to your cat’s diet.

American Journey Grain-Free Diets

American Journey Grain-Free Diets

The grain-free American Journey product line is one of the most popular options. These diets are specifically formulated to enhance protein content and provide an extensive amino acid profile, an essential foundation for any cat’s diet.

Cats with sensitives stomachs or skin may find a grain-free formula a suitable option. These diets exclude common allergen ingredients such as artificial preservatives, soy, wheat, or corn which may cause adverse reactions for cats with allergies.

Additional vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants come from whole ingredients like carrots, blueberries, or potatoes, supporting overall health and providing a balanced nutritional meal for your cat.

Although most cats need grains to assist with digestion, American Journey ensures that its formulas provide appropriate, alternative, high-quality ingredients rich in fiber.  

American Journey Indoor Cat Diets

American Journey Indoor Cat Diets

American Journey Indoor cat food formulas are specifically formulated to give additional nutritional support to indoor cats. These cat foods offer well-balanced nutrition and additional fiber content to aid in digestion while restricting excessive calories.

Animal-based protein sources provide the building blocks of all these indoor cat diets. The protein content is lower than many of the Landmark formulas but still offers suitable ingredients that promote muscle mass and essential amino acids.

These grain-free formulas use a mixture of soluble and insoluble dietary fibers like pea protein. This provides an easily digestible source of carbohydrates that aid in digestion and promote beneficial bacteria in the GI tract. The use of these fibers helps prevent hairballs, which indoor cats are prone to suffering from.

The added use of whole fruits and vegetables provides natural antioxidants and vitamins to help develop a healthy immune system. 

Healthy fatty ingredients like flaxseed and fish oil offer a suitable mixture of omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids fundamental to a well-balanced diet. 

American Journey Landmark

American Journey Landmark

American Journey offers a product line called Landmark, a premium canned recipe inspired by your cat’s natural ancestral diet. These wet foods provide a more expensive option that is more affordable compared to other premium brands.

These grain-free canned foods feature an impressive ratio of 95% animal-based ingredients and 5% whole fruits and vegetables that make an ideal diet for many cats.

Multiple meat proteins offer a wide variety of amino acids. A moderate fat content complements the rich-protein formulas and contributes beneficial fat and moderate caloric content.

The inclusion of broths adds texture and moisture needed for many cats as they typically obtain hydration through their diet.

American Journey also excludes grains, corn, wheat, soy and sometimes excludes common allergen ingredients like peas or potatoes. The elimination of such ingredients further substantiates their approach of “protein-first.”

American Journey Wet Food

The American Journey Wet Food features a product range of different flavors that appeal to many picky eaters. The range of canned cat food from American Journey comes either in the form of minced or pate to give cat owners various options that remain relatively affordable.

The grain-free canned formulas feature a wide range of meats, such as chicken, turkey, beef, salmon, or tuna. These high-quality meats support your cat with added amino acids that help lean muscle development and taurine.

Wholesome fruit or vegetables provide natural sources of phytonutrients and antioxidants, which aid brain functions in cats, support a healthy immune system, and promote bone, joint, eye, and heart health.

These protein-rich recipes also provide the perfect balance of omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids like EPA and DHA, promoting healthy coats and skin for cats.

Most cats prefer the texture of wet cat food compared to kibble. And canned foods usually contain less filler ingredients such as artificial preservatives, grains, or poultry by-products. 

Many cat owners highly recommend these American Journey wet foods for their unique flavor, particularly for picky eaters.


What Do Customers Think Of American Journey?

I spent a few days researching several forums and customer reviews on Chewy. Overall, customers like American Journey cat food because of its affordability and high-quality ingredients.

Some of the most popular choices among cat owners were the kibbles, with some wet foods getting only moderate ratings. 

Most negative reviews told stories of their picky eaters not liking how the food tasted or refusing to eat it.

Positive Reviews

The bag is easy to open & seals to close nicely. My cat enjoys this new dry food which actually smells like real meat.

Review from American Journey Turkey & Chicken Dry Cat Food.

Switching from Blue Buffalo (sensitive stomach “formula”) to this one was literally the best choice for my cat. I transitioned her to it slowly and she loves it so much. She used to throw up every day on Blue Buffalo and now she doesn’t puke at all and it makes me so happy that I found something that helps her feel more comfortable.

Review from American Journey Duck Recipe Dry Cat Food.

I love my little girl but she’s the pickiest eater I have ever adopted!!! We have gone through at least 30 different of brand of kitten/cat food but nothing!!!! I have tried all kinds of things like organic chicken breast, freeze dried foods and the refrigerated food but she would refused to eat them. She would just smell the food and pretend she was covering them up (like poop). I kept reading and searching for healthy options. I read the ingredients of American Journey and thought let me try this. My husband and I were shocked, Jazmin actually ate it!!! No covering up!!! Seriously Ms. Picky girl even cleaned her bowl!!!! We are so very happy and relieved that we found a healthy food that my kitty loves!!!

Review from American Journey Minced Chicken Canned Cat Food.

Negative Reviews

My cat refused to eat the canned food. Even when I tried to slowly switch him over even if there was a little bit of this canned stuff in his bowl he refused to eat

Review from American Journey Pate Beef Canned Cat Food

It appears healthy and natural but my fussy girl is having no part of it. She sniffed and walked away. Tried it again, same results. Can’t really rate this item may be other cats favorite, not mine.

Review from American Journey Landmark Chicken Canned Cat Food.


Top Three American Journey Recipes Reviewed

Here are three of the best American Journey recipes. 

All of these foods meet the minimum nutrient requirements set out by the AAFCO. [4]

American Journey Turkey Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

American Journey Turkey & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
  • First 5 Ingredients: Deboned Turkey, Turkey Meal, Chicken Meal, Tapioca Starch, Dried Egg Product
  • Guaranteed Analysis: 40% Protein, 15% Fat, 4% Fiber, 10% Moisture
  • Dry Matter Analysis: 44.44% Protein, 16.67% Fat, 4.44% Fiber
  • Estimated Carbohydrates: 31%
  • Caloric Content: 3,670 kcal/kg, 395 kcal/cup
  • Key Features: Grain-Free, No Corn No Wheat No Soy, High-Protein
  • Life Stage: Adult

This affordable protein-rich recipe features numerous meat-based protein sources that replicate your cat’s ancestral diet.

Deboned turkey is the first ingredient on the list, mainly contributing to the formula’s unique 40% crude protein content. Added turkey meal and chicken meal provide adequate amino acids that are fundamental nutrients your cat’s body needs to function.

The formula also contains menhaden fish and dried egg protein to boost the overall nutritional content of this American Journey cat food. 

Like many grain-free formulas, this cat food uses pea protein and whole peas to provide additional vitamins and antioxidants. Added probiotics and dietary fibers come from ingredients like apples, blueberries, carrots, or pumpkin, which assist in digestive processes.

The moderate 395 kcal/cup caloric content of the recipe and average 31% carbohydrates make this American journey cat food suitable for most cats. 

American Journey Salmon Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

American Journey Salmon Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
  • First 5 Ingredients: Deboned Salmon, Salmon Meal, Tapioca Starch, Menhaden Fish Meal, Dried Egg Product
  • Guaranteed Analysis: 40% Protein, 15% Fat, 4% Fiber, 10% Moisture
  • Dry Matter Analysis: 44.44% Protein, 16.67% Fat, 4.44% Fiber
  • Estimated Carbohydrates: 31%
  • Caloric Content: 3,815 kcal/kg, 410 kcal/cup
  • Key Features: Grain-Free, No Corn No Wheat No Soy, High-Protein
  • Life Stage: Adult

Like the last product we discussed, rather than deboned turkey as the primary protein source, this recipe features deboned salmon and salmon meal that largely contributes to the 40% crude protein.

These meat-based proteins provide suitable omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids that promote healthy skin and coat in cats. Likewise, the use of meat-based protein ingredients replicates a cat’s ancestral diet.

While this formula does contain some plant-based protein ingredients, the salmonmenhaden fish meal, and dried egg product pack the cat food with enough protein content to make it a balanced, nutritional meal.

Added vitamin-rich whole ingredients provide beneficial antioxidants from cranberries, spinach, and pumpkin, which offer the perfect blend of dietary fibers that promote the digestion of the beneficial nutrients. 

The slightly higher 410 kcal/cup caloric content of this American Journey recipe may be unsuitable for cats with a less active lifestyle like indoor cats, in addition to cats with obesity or weight-related conditions.

The exclusion of common allergen ingredients like wheat, soy, corn, and grains makes it a popular choice for cat owners.

American Journey Pate Turkey & Salmon Canned Cat Food

American Journey Pate Turkey & Salmon Recipe Grain-Free Canned Cat Food
  • First 5 Ingredients: Turkey, Turkey Broth, Turkey Liver, Salmon, Natural Flavor
  • Guaranteed Analysis: 10% Protein, 6% Fat, 1% Fiber, 78% Moisture
  • Dry Matter Analysis: 45.45% Protein, 27.27% Fat, 4.55% Fiber
  • Estimated Carbohydrates: 5%
  • Caloric Content: 1,150 kcal/kg, 407 kcal/can
  • Key Features: Grain-Free, No Corn No Wheat No Soy, Pea-Free
  • Life Stage: Adult

This grain-free wet food from American Journey primarily gets its protein content from turkey, turkey liver, and whole salmon. 

To compare wet foods accurately with dry foods, you need to do so on a dry matter basis. This is because of the higher moisture content in most wet cat foods. 

The use of meat-based proteins ensures a high 45.45% crude protein content (dry matter basis). These ingredients provide sufficient omega-3 fatty acids and taurine levels. 

Healthy fat is boosted by the inclusion of fish oil in this canned food. Ingredients such as cassia gum, xanthan gum, whole fruits like cranberries and blueberries ensure suitable dietary fibers that help with digestion.

This formula also excluded common allergen ingredients such as artificial preservatives, flavors, by-products, grains, corn, wheat, and soy. 


American Journey Cat Food Recalls

To date, there have been no recalls of any American Journey cat foods. However, it is worth noting that American Journey is a relatively new product line that started in 2017.

This company has little history, but they still enforce rigid safety and quality standards to ensure their products are safe to consume.

Click this link to find a complete list of all cat food recalls sorted by date by the FDA. [5]

However, American Journey also manufacturers dog foods; if you have a dog, try out our dog food recalls list.

Final Verdict 

This American Journey cat food review shows that a new product line can still offer high-quality nutrition for cats while being backed by the experience of a reputable online food retailer.

I recommend American Journey cat food for cat owners who want to feed their cats high-quality ingredients. Most formulas from American Journey are rich in amino acids and nutrients your cat needs to live a healthy life while remaining affordable!

In fact, the ingredients used by American Journey are unrivaled by most affordable pet food brands.

Chewy offers its exclusive products at an affordable price by streamlining production processes and then passing these savings onto customers. Some cat owners even switch to American Journey from premium cat food brands.

Discuss with your veterinarian today whether American Journey cat food is the best choice for your furry friend.

James Fuller

James Fuller

Founder of Honest Whiskers

Hey! I’ve owned a pet pretty much all my life, in fact, I currently have both a cat and a dog! My mission is to deliver a reliable, trusted website that only uses evidence-based information

Dogs and Cat
Looking for pet food?

Save 30% on your next order

We have partnered with Chewy.com to give you the best deals on top brands of pet food for our readers. Simply click the button below and we’ll take you to their exclusive discount page!

Looking for pet food?

Save 30% on your next order

We have partnered with Chewy.com to give you the best deals on top brands of pet food for our readers. Simply click the button below and we’ll take you to their exclusive discount page!